The First "41st"
At the end of the wars against the French in the first part
of the 18th century, the British army was greatly reduced in size
as a cost-saving measure. It was also decided to raise garrison
companies of 'veterans' to garrison key positions in the United
Kingdom, thus freeing up 'regular' regiments for field service.
These companies were gathered together for administrative purposes
in 1719 and became 'Colonel Fielding's Regiment of Invalids'.
In 1751, the Regiment was given the number "41".
Contrary to what the modern reader might expect from the "invalid"
title, the original members of the Regiment were well-trained
veterans of Marlborough's campaigns and were a respectable force.
An "invalid" was simply a pensioner, whether disabled
or not. But as the century progressed, the personnel of the 41st
apparently degenerated in to men of whom the term "invalid" increasingly
had its current meaning, and the unit became unfit
even for garrison duties.
The decision was therefore taken to turn the 41st in to a "marching"
regiment in late 1787. In a very real sense, the Regiment was
reborn, the "invalids" were all pensioned off and new
men recruited.
The 41st: Incarnation #2
The men who formed the Regiment after its change to "marching"
status in 1787 inherited the Regimental Number "41",
but no history of proud achievements by their predecessors. They
were, to all intents and purposes, starting afresh. Because the
"Invalid" regiment had recruited all across the U.K.,
the 'new' 41st also did: it received no title or county affiliation
until the 1820's, when the 41st became the Welch Regiment. At
the time of the War of 1812, the 41st had as its designation solely
its number - and it continued to recruit its men from anywhere
in Britain and Ireland.
The first field service of the 41st was in the West Indies. From
1793 to 1796, the Regiment saw action at Martinique, St. Lucia,
Guadeloupe, and San Domingo, but it was sickness, not enemy action,
that decimated its ranks. When the 41st was pulled back to Portsmouth
in October of 1796, only the surviving officers and NCO's were
taken, the few remaining (presumably well-acclimatized) privates
were transferred in to the 17th Foot.
The 41st: Incarnation #3
After its hellacious spell of duty in the West Indies, the
Regiment recruited itself up to strength again in Britain and
Ireland, before being sent off to Canada in August of 1799. Only
a few of its personnel had operational experience gained in the
West Indies. In effect, it was "incarnation #3" of the
Regiment that would see duty in the War of 1812. It remained a
unit without a single earned Battle Honour on its Colours.
In the years before the outbreak of the War of 1812, the 41st
had its ups and downs as it was shifted frequently between Lower
and Upper Canada, performing garrison duties. Upper Canada was
a particularly hard station for a Regiment to keep itself sharp
in, as individual companies and even smaller elements of the Regiment
would be detached to garrison a number of posts strung out along
the long frontier. Each return to Lower Canada saw efforts made
to again increase the combat readiness of the reunited Regiment.
Reinforcements and new equipment were sent out periodically as
well. In 1809, a major reinforcement was received, that included
Private Shadrach Byfield, perhaps the best-known member of the
Regiment during the War of 1812, as he authored the only extended "ranker" account
of the War currently known to exist.
On the eve of the War, the Regiment was in good shape. Its men
were all fairly young and healthy, their equipment in acceptable
condition. In fact, the Regiment had been about to be withdrawn
to Europe, where it probably would have ended up in Wellington's
forces in Spain. However, the impending outbreak of the War of
1812 led to the decision to keep the 41st in Upper Canada. Not
only was it up to strength, it was fully acclimatized to Canadian
conditions, which must have been an important factor in what was
to follow.
Services of the 41st in the War of 1812
1812 Campaigns
At the outbreak of the War, the 41st was the only full British
regiment in Upper Canada and as such would bear the principal
burden - and earn the glory - of repelling the initial American
attacks.
Simply stated, General Brock, in command in Upper Canada, faced
a strategic dilemma: large American forces were gathering to invade
on both the Niagara and Detroit Rivers. His solution to this problem
was to shift most of his men to the Detroit frontier, capture
Detroit, then shift his strength back to the Niagara front. Sounds
simple, sounds obvious - yet any student of the Detroit campaign
must be aghast at the sheer bravado displayed by Brock, and the
magnitude of the risks he ran. But desperate times make for desperate
measures.
Luckily for Canada, Brock's gamble paid off.
The 41st formed the main element in the Anglo-Canadian forces
that captured Detroit in August of 1812, with the assistance of
native allies in a coalition the dominant personality of which
was Tecumseh.
The strength of the 41st was then shifted back to the Niagara
front and formed the main element of the force which crushed the
subsequent American invasion at the Battle of Queenston Heights
in October.
The Regiment had earned its first two Battle Honours - "Detroit"
and "Queenstown".
However, the picture at the end of 1812 was not all rosy. While
some reinforcements had arrived in Upper Canada, the talented
Brock had been killed at Queenston Heights, and the Americans
were making preparations to redeem their earlier mistakes. The
41st found itself split, its companies attempting to guard both
the Niagara and Detroit frontiers, with the Regiment's Colonel,
Henry Procter, in command of the "Right Division" on
the Detroit frontier.
A major element and consideration in all operations on the Detroit
front involved the western native allies, but Procter would prove
unable to forge as productive a relationship with Tecumseh as
Brock had. It appears that the average soldier of the 41st also
had more fear than affection for his native comrade in arms.
1813 Campaigns
The first American counter-attack occurred on the Detroit
frontier. A January offensive by General Henry Harrison led to
an aggressive counter-punch by Procter at Winchester's isolated
and exposed American command at Frenchtown (now Monroe, Michigan)
on January 22, 1813. Although Procter achieved strategic and tactical
surprise, his resulting battle tactics threw the advantage away,
and in the desperate fighting which resulted, the companies of
the 41st present suffered over 50% casualties. Luckily, the native
allies managed to break and overrun the American right flank and
the result of the battle was the destruction of Winchester's force,
thus crippling Harrison's overall "winter-campaign"
strategy. Unfortunately, Procter, in his desire to get his mauled
forces back to the security of the Detroit River forts (Amherstburg
and Detroit) abandoned American wounded to the not-so-tender mercies
of the native allies. The resulting "River Raisin Massacre" would form
a rallying cry for Americans for the rest of the War.
Harrison concentrated his remaining forces on the Maumee River
near what is now Toledo, Ohio, and commenced construction of Fort
Meigs to act as a base for his next offensive. The Americans had
set in play a shipbuilding program on both Lake Ontario and Lake
Erie, and the isolated position of the Right Division on the Detroit
front deteriorated steadily as the year 1813 progressed.
Although the need to reinforce Procter's Right Division was recognized
by the "High Command" in Montreal and orders were sent
to the Center Division to forward the remaining companies of the
41st to Procter, events on the Niagara front precluded this possibility.
Thus, companies of the 41st were present when the Americans attacked
and captured Fort George in May of 1813, and these companies formed
the garrison of Burlington Heights when the rest of the Center
Division made their successful night attack on the American camp
at Stoney Creek on June 6. Although the Center Division in effect
disobeyed orders to send the 41st companies on to Procter, they
at least were kept as an emergency reserve and thus did not get
shot up in either of these major confrontations. Individual officers
of the 41st were involved in both actions.
Meanwhile, Procter had decided to use the Right Division for a
spoiling attack on Fort Meigs. The first siege, in late April/early
May, resulted in the destruction of a large force of American
reinforcements in 'Dudley's Defeat', and some hard fighting as
the Americans attacked the siege batteries - but it proved impossible
for the smaller Right Division to actually capture the American
fort given its commanding position and very large garrison. There
was another ugly incident involving American prisoners being maltreated
by some of the native allies, in which an infantryman of the 41st
attempting to protect the Americans was himself "chopped".
Fortunately Tecumseh arrived in time to stop a major massacre.
Despite the overall disappointing results from this operation,
the 41st earned the Battle Honour "Miami" (the Maumee
River was also called the "Miami" at this time).
As progress on what would become Commodore Perry's U.S. Lake Erie
squadron relentlessly continued, and reports of the forces Harrison
was gathering came in, Procter became more and more despondent.
In July, at the insistence of the Indian Allies, Procter again
led the Right Division out in a spoiling attack against Fort Meigs.
The "Second Siege" (July 21-26 1813) accomplished even
less than the first, and Procter decided to attack Fort Stephenson
(Fremont, Ohio), basically a fortified supply depot, which he
thought would be "easy pickings". On August 2, 1813,
Procter ordered an attempt to escalade the American fort, but
the unexpected presence of an American artillery piece, plus the
unwillingness of the American garrison to surrender (natural enough,
given the several 'massacres' that had already occurred when Procter
proved unable to protect his prisoners), led to a bloody repulse
of the attack columns and a precipitate retreat back to the Detroit
forts. And, the bottoming-out of the 41st's faith in their commander's
battlefield skills.
As the completed American Squadron on Lake Erie took dominance
of the Lake, Procter sat in the Detroit River forts, receiving
only limited reinforcements from the Center Division (most of
the 1st Battalion eventually reached him). He waited for the completion
of the new British flagship for the Lake Erie squadron, H.M.S.
Detroit, and watched his food stocks deplete at an alarming rate.
Finally, the "Detroit" was as complete as resources
at Amherstburg could make her, the food was almost gone, and the
only honourable choice left was to go out and try and win back
command of Lake Erie. Procter placed 150 men of the 41st on Barclay's
squadron as marines, and on September 10, 1813, the two squadrons
hammered it out off Put-In-Bay. The result was the destruction
and capture of the British squadron, the loss of all its manpower,
and the knowledge that Perry's fleet could now with impunity ferry
Harrison's large army to anywhere on the north shore of Lake Erie,
thereby cutting Procter's communications with the Center Division.
Procter's decision to retreat to a position on the lower Thames
was ineptly carried out and in the early afternoon of October
5, 1813, what was left of the 1/41st found itself just west of
Moraviantown strung out in an overly-extended formation in light
woods, facing overwhelming numbers of Americans. The 41st's "battle" lasted
about 10 minutes, as a column of American mounted infantry charged and overran
the left flank of 41st line on a narrow frontage,
then turned left and neatly rolled it up.
Indians on the right flank posed a more serious threat to the
Americans, until Tecumseh was killed. Indian resistance meant
some men on the right of the 41st's line managed to escape the
disaster. Only 6 subalterns, 9 sergeants, 6 drummers, and 159
rank and file of the 41st made it to the Center Division at Burlington
Heights - and not all of these men had been present at the battle.
The Second Battalion
Only the fact the 41st's 2nd battalion had arrived in Canada
in the spring of 1813 enabled the Regiment to reorganize as a
single battalion, and carry on operations as a viable force.
The Second Battalion, with a strength of 500 men, had sailed from
Ireland on 20 March 1813, and arrived at Quebec City May 15, 1813.
At that point, 400 men were to be "sent on" to Upper
Canada, 100 "boys" were retained in the Quebec City
garrison. By June 24 1813, 100 men of the 2nd Battalion were being
formally transferred in to the 1st Battalion and forwarded to
Procter. The balance of the 2nd Battalion spent the summer and
early fall of 1813 as part of the Left Division, garrisoning the
St. Lawrence River posts; its personnel were involved in a number
of small actions with the Americans.
By August 22 1813, Prevost was writing to inform Procter that
he had ordered the balance of the 2nd battalion to Amherstburg
and on that date, it in fact received orders to move from Prescott
to Kingston. By 1 October 1813, 160 men of the 2nd Battalion had
reached Burlington Heights. They were still there when the remains
of the 1st Battalion marched in.
In 1813, men of the Regiment's two battalions had been stationed spread out from Montreal to Fort Malden - and Captain Richard Bullock of the Grenadier Company commanded the garrison at Mackinac from September 13, 1813, to May 18, 1814! The Regiment had seen much hard service on all fronts.
The Unified Battalion - Incarnation #3.1 - December 1813,
1814 Campaigns
Given the small size of the 2nd battalion and the small number
of survivors from the 1st, the decision was taken to combine them
in to one unit. This combined '1st/2nd' battalion was what conducted
the 41st's operations for the balance of the War. It was a somewhat
uneven, ad hoc unit in that it was composed partly of tough, experienced,
and battle-hardened veterans of the 1st battalion, and partly
of the relatively new and inexperienced recruits of the 2nd. It
appears that the best men were put in to the flank companies and
continued to see heavy action, while the regular line companies
were utilised mainly in support roles.
By December 19 1813, the combined battalion supplied flank companies
for the assault on Fort Niagara, while the line companies helped
capture Lewiston.
On December 30 1813, an attack was launched on Black Rock & Buffalo, with
250 men of the 41st participating, suffering casualties of 2 killed, 5 wounded,
and 3 missing.
On 9 January 1814, Drummond ordered the 41st ordered to York;
on February 8, they were ordered from York to Kingston.
The 41st found itself back on the Niagara Peninsula in time to
help repel the last major American offensive of the War.
At the Battle of Lundy's Lane in July 1814, the Light Company
of the 41st under Captain Glew managed to distinguish itself.
In Drummond's subsequent operations in pursuit of the retreating
Americans, Colonel Tucker (with most of the 41st under his command)
managed to bungle an attack on Black Rock. This was a relatively
unremarkable occasion except that Shadrach Byfield was wounded,
losing an arm, and started on his long journey back to his Wiltshire
home.
The Regiment participated in the siege of Fort Erie, with the
flank companies taking heavy casualties in the failed night assault
of August 15. At that point, the Regiment was pulled back to form
part of the garrison of "the forts" at the mouth of
the Niagara River: Fort Niagara, Fort George, and Fort Mississauga.
It was found that the 41st was the most useful unit to garrison
Fort Niagara, as other units placed there suffered from excessive
desertion rates.
Eventually, the Regiment was withdrawn to York, then Kingston.
It had earned its 4th Battle Honour in the War of 1812: "Niagara",
for its participation in the 1814 Niagara Peninsula campaign.
After the War
In the spring of 1815, with its men who had been American
prisoners repatriated, the Regiment embarked for Britain, with
approximately 1,200 men of the unified battalion on the transport.
The Regiment was diverted to Belgium, arriving just too late for
Waterloo, but in time to help occupy Paris. The contrast between
conditions in the backwoods of Upper Canada and the French capital,
must have seemed surreal to the average infantryman of the Regiment.
Distinguishing Features of the 41st:
The 41st's "facing colour" (i.e. the colour of the
collar, cuffs, and shoulder straps of its redcoat) was red; its
regimental lace, white with a centered black line, set on in bastion
looping of the 'jew's harp' design.
Because of its "red on red" uniform, the 41st displayed
some out of the norm attributes in terms of its Regimental Colours
(standards) and in the uniforms of its musicians. The Regimental
Colour resembled a Royal Naval White Ensign, but "squared"
to a 6 foot by 6 foot size. The King's Colour conformed to normal
regulations. During the War, the Regiment's Colours of course
had no Battle Honours - new Colours issued in 1816 proudly bore
"Detroit", "Queenstown", "Miami",
and "Niagara".
Since 41st musicians could not utilise the army's normal 'reversed'
colour pattern (i.e. main body of coat the facing colour, faced
with red) to set them apart from the regular infantrymen, they
instead had white coats, faced red, with an elaborate special
lace applied, much more liberally than on a regular infantryman's
redcoat (as on all regiments' musician coats).
The 1st battalion started the War with pre-1812 pattern "stove-pipe" shakos
and might never have been reequipped until returning to Europe. Officer's uniforms
had silver buttons and silver lace
with a black line centered, applied in the same bastion loop pattern
as the enlisted men.
The 2nd battalion almost undoubtedly arrived in Canada with the
new 1812 (or "Belgic") shako, although the infantryman's
red coat would have been the same as that of a member of the 1st
battalion. Officers of the 2nd battalion had gold buttons and
gold lace applied in square-ended loops; officers of the 1st battalion
and then the amalgamated battalion were also ordered to adopt
this pattern.
Summary.
The 41st Regiment of Foot and its successor, The Royal Regiment
of Wales (24th/41st Foot), has never been stationed in Canada
again. But its links with Canada can never be broken.
During its extended stay (1799 to 1815), and especially during
the War, it left its dead scattered across most of the garrisons
and fighting fronts in the Canadas.
Equally important, many men of the Regiment, when they received
their discharges in the years after the War of 1812, returned
to Canada - but this time, as settlers, taking up land grants
earned by their services in defence of the colonies.
The men of the 41st played a vital role in the defence of Canada
in the War of 1812; their numerous descendants have helped build
the country ever since.